duck

Thanksgiving 2026: The Turkey Costs More, but the Biggest Surprise Is at the Butcher Shop on a Corner

News & Updates

Master butcher Stephen Kitar explains why Sam’s Meat Warehouse is skipping fresh turkeys this year—and why the smartest Thanksgiving purchase might not be a turkey at all.

By Kat Leslie

Thanksgiving is approaching, and Americans are once again preparing for that cherished annual tradition: gathering with family, counting their blessings, and discovering that the bird in the middle of the table has developed a rather impressive opinion of its own market value.

Turkey prices are climbing. Grocery bills remain a concern. And somewhere between the pumpkin pie and the cranberry sauce, holiday shopping has become a contest between consumers trying to save money and retailers trying to persuade them that ordinary poultry has suddenly acquired extraordinary qualities.

But this year, one local butcher is refusing to play along.

Stephen Kitar, master butcher at Sam’s Meat Warehouse and host of WTBQ’s Food for Thought radio program, has an unexpected announcement:

Sam’s Meat Warehouse will not be carrying fresh whole turkeys this Thanksgiving.

For a meat business heading into one of the busiest food holidays of the year, that sounds almost unthinkable.

Kitar sees it differently.

“We’re Not Selling a Holiday Surcharge Disguised as a Tradition”

“Sam’s has always operated on a simple principle: Bring our customers the best available product at the best available price,” Kitar explained.

“If I can’t look a customer in the eye and justify what we’re charging, I don’t want that product in my meat case.”

Kitar says the decision is not about abandoning Thanksgiving traditions. It is about refusing to participate in a seasonal pricing frenzy that can leave customers paying a substantial premium for products that may not be substantially different from less expensive alternatives.

“People have been conditioned to believe that Thanksgiving requires a turkey, preferably one with a fancy name, an impressive label, and a price tag that makes the butcher look like he’s selling jewelry.”

He paused.

“It’s a turkey. Not a Rolex.”

Yes, there is a legitimate distinction between fresh and frozen poultry. Fresh birds require more precise processing, transportation, and inventory timing, while frozen turkeys can be produced and stored well ahead of the holiday.

But Kitar argues that a higher price should reflect a genuine difference in quality, production, or service—not merely the calendar.

“Thanksgiving comes every November. It isn’t an unexpected emergency. And consumers shouldn’t have to treat buying dinner like bidding at an auction.”

The Numbers Behind the Bird

The latest figures suggest that shoppers have reason to be price-conscious.

According to the USDA, the projected average wholesale price for frozen whole hen turkeys in 2026 is approximately $1.76 per pound, compared with $1.36 in 2025.

Texas A&M AgriLife Extension reported that conventional frozen whole turkeys averaged approximately $1.26 per pound at grocery stores in early November, compared with $1.03 a year earlier.

That is an increase of roughly 22%.

But here is the twist: turkey production has rebounded, and agricultural economists expect adequate holiday supplies.

In other words, Kitar explains, prices are higher, but there is no evidence of a nationwide shortage requiring consumers to pay almost anything for a Thanksgiving bird.

He believes shoppers should remember that distinction.

“Higher production costs are real. So are transportation, labor, refrigeration, and the expense of keeping a fresh product available for a very narrow selling window. I’m not suggesting retailers should work for free.”

“But there’s a difference between recovering legitimate costs and asking customers to pay an extraordinary premium because it’s Thanksgiving.”

The $9.99 Turkey: What Exactly Are You Paying For?

Kitar recently learned of an advertisement from another local meat retailer when a customer brought it to his attention. The advertisement promoted a “Premium All-Natural Nicholas Breed Turkey,” described as locally raised, tender, and flavorful.

The asking price?

$9.99 per pound.

At that price, a 16-pound turkey would cost $159.84.

A 20-pound bird would cost $199.80.

And that is before credit card surcharges that store charges, bag fee, fee fee, etc. Now add the potatoes, vegetables, stuffing, gravy, desserts—or the family member who insists Thanksgiving isn’t complete without three different kinds of pie.

“What caught my attention wasn’t simply the price,” Kitar said. “It was the language being used to justify it.”

Consider the words.

Premium.

All-natural.

Nicholas breed.

Locally raised.

They sound impressive. But what do they actually tell the buyer?

Nicholas is not an obscure heritage turkey known only to a handful of small farms. It is a high-yield commercial turkey breed designed for efficient production associated with Aviagen Turkeys, a major poultry genetics company. It is not inherently a heritage or rare breed. It is a common, if not dominant, turkey breed known for efficient growth, meat yield, and feed conversion—precisely the characteristics commercial poultry producers value.

That does not make a Nicholas turkey inferior. It makes the name of the line a poor substitute for evidence of exceptional farming practices or eating quality.

“That’s like advertising a premium chicken because it comes with feathers,” Kitar laughed. “Of course it’s a Nicholas turkey. That’s one of the commercial breeding lines used throughout the industry. Now tell me what makes this particular bird worth five times the price.”

 

The term natural deserves similar scrutiny.

Under USDA labeling rules, natural meat and poultry generally means minimally processed and containing no artificial ingredients. It does not, by itself, establish that a turkey was pasture-raised, organically fed, raised slowly, or produced on a small farm.

And locally raised may be a meaningful advantage when supported by a traceable farm and documented production practices. But geography alone does not tell the whole story.

Kitar’s advice is straightforward:

“Ask where the bird was raised, what it was fed, how it was processed, whether anything was added to it, and what makes it different from the conventional turkey at the supermarket.”

“If the seller can’t explain the difference without repeating the adjectives on the sign, perhaps the adjectives are what you’re paying for.”

But at $9.99/lb it is a price that deserves an explanation.

What About Those Free Supermarket Turkeys?

Kitar is equally skeptical of the idea that expensive automatically means better.

“Here’s something most Thanksgiving shoppers probably don’t realize,” Kitar explained. “That deeply discounted turkey at the supermarket could very well come from the same Nicholas commercial breeding line as a bird advertised for $9.99 a pound.”

Large supermarket chains frequently offer heavily discounted or even complimentary turkeys when customers meet minimum spending requirements.

Those promotions are possible because turkey is often a loss leader—an item sold cheaply to attract shoppers who will purchase the rest of their holiday groceries.

“There’s nothing wrong with taking advantage of that,” Kitar said. “If a supermarket offers a good turkey at a good price, take it. That’s smart shopping.”

He cautions, however, against comparing a promotional supermarket price directly with the operating costs of a small independent retailer.

“The big stores can afford to give away the bird because they’re hoping to sell you everything else. An independent butcher doesn’t have that same business model.”

Still, Kitar says the difference in business models does not justify extravagant pricing claims.

“Customers deserve an honest explanation of what they’re buying. That’s the whole point.”

And here’s another question worth asking,” Kitar added. “If a retailer is comfortable charging $9.99 a pound for a commercially bred turkey, what should customers expect to pay for everything else in that meat case?” 

“We understand that production and operating costs have risen, but a nearly $10-per-pound turkey deserves a very convincing explanation. At Sam’s, we’ve always believed that earning a customer’s trust is worth more than making a killing on a single holiday sale.”

“Looking back over the years, Sam’s Meat Warehouse has consistently offered fresh, never-frozen turkeys, including specialty heritage breeds, at prices ranging from just $1.99 to $2.49 per pound,” Kitar recalled. “At Sam’s, our philosophy has never been to see how much we can charge. It’s been to see how much quality we can deliver for a fair price.”

So What’s for Thanksgiving if There’s No Turkey?

This is where Kitar’s announcement takes a more appetizing turn.

Rather than competing in the fresh-turkey market, Sam’s Meat Warehouse plans to emphasize alternative holiday centerpieces, including goose, duck, capon, and other specialty meats, subject to availability.

“Thanksgiving doesn’t have to mean eating the same bird every year simply because that’s what the calendar tells us to do.”

A goose, he explained, offers rich, dark meat and a traditional holiday presentation. Duck delivers deep flavor and beautifully crisp skin when properly prepared. Capon—a specially raised male chicken—provides generous, tender meat and an elegant roast that is particularly appealing to families who prefer chicken.

“People sometimes forget that holiday cooking was about choosing something special, not necessarily choosing something enormous.”

Unlike commercial turkeys, which are raised throughout the year, specialty poultry production often involves smaller flocks and more limited availability. Goose production in particular can reflect seasonal breeding and marketing patterns.

Kitar suggests reserving specialty birds early rather than waiting until the final days before Thanksgiving.

“And don’t assume that a more expensive price per pound automatically means a more expensive dinner. Think about how many people you’re feeding, how much edible meat you’re getting, and how much food ends up in the refrigerator afterward.”

A Master Butcher’s Thanksgiving Buying Advice

Kitar offers several practical suggestions for getting better value without sacrificing the holiday meal.

Buy for the number of people, not the size of your roasting pan. A smaller gathering may be better served by a capon, a duck, a turkey breast, or two smaller roasts rather than an oversized whole bird.

Compare the actual product. Fresh, frozen, organic, heritage, pasture-raised, and conventionally raised poultry are not interchangeable descriptions. Some identify regulated production methods; others are broad marketing language. Ask what the label means.

Check for added solutions. Some poultry is injected or enhanced with water, broth, salt, or other ingredients. Read the ingredient statement and the percentage of added solution, if any. That matters when comparing prices and seasoning the meat.

Don’t confuse a beautiful bird with a tender bird. Proper thawing, cooking temperature, resting, and carving often make a bigger difference to the finished meal than an impressive package.

Use a thermometer, not a prayer. Poultry should reach a safe internal temperature of 165°F. Guessing based on color or the clock is an unnecessary holiday gamble.

Plan the leftovers. Bones can become stock, cooked meat can become soup or sandwiches, and rendered duck or goose fat can be saved for roasting potatoes.

“Some of the best meals come from what people would otherwise throw away,” Kitar said. “A good butcher teaches you how to use the whole product.”

Stephen’s Holiday Alternative: Roast Duck With Apples and Onions

 

For families willing to depart from the traditional turkey, Kitar suggests a simple roast duck that combines rich poultry flavor with the sweetness of Hudson Valley apples.

Ingredients

  • One whole duck, approximately 4–6 pounds
  • Two firm apples, quartered
  • Two onions, quartered
  • Two teaspoons kosher salt, adjusted for bird size
  • Freshly ground black pepper
  • A few sprigs of thyme or rosemary
  • Optional: a little apple cider for the pan sauce

Method

Pat the duck thoroughly dry. Remove any giblets and excess loose fat. Carefully score or prick the skin in fatty areas without piercing the meat, allowing the fat to render during roasting.

Season inside and out with salt and pepper. Place the apples, onions, and herbs loosely in the cavity for aroma, without tightly stuffing the bird.

Roast on a rack in a shallow pan at 350°F, allowing approximately 30–35 minutes per pound as a planning guide. Drain accumulated fat carefully when necessary.

Use a meat thermometer to verify that the thickest parts of the breast and thigh reach at least 165°F. If the skin needs additional crisping, briefly increase the oven temperature while watching closely.

Rest before carving. Serve with roasted apples, onions, and potatoes cooked separately in a little of the rendered duck fat.

“Duck gives you something turkey doesn’t: enough flavorful fat to make the potatoes almost as memorable as the bird,” Kitar said.

“And if you’re cooking Thanksgiving dinner, that’s not a bad bonus.”

The Best Thanksgiving Deal Is an Honest One

For Kitar, the decision not to carry fresh turkeys is ultimately about something more important than poultry.

It is about trust.

“Sam’s Meat Warehouse has always believed that the customer should get a fair deal. Sometimes that means bringing in a product we’re excited about. Sometimes it means saying no to a product whose price we simply can’t justify.”

He has no objection to a customer buying an expensive heritage turkey from a farmer who can explain exactly why it costs more.

Nor does he object to a family taking advantage of a supermarket promotion.

What troubles him is the notion that Thanksgiving shoppers should feel obligated to pay inflated prices because of tradition, fear of missing out, or a collection of attractive marketing words.

“The holiday is supposed to be about gratitude, family, and sharing a meal. Not seeing how much money somebody can extract from the person responsible for cooking it.”

And for anyone disappointed that Sam’s won’t be selling fresh turkeys this year, Kitar offers a final thought.

“Come talk to your butcher. Tell us how many people you’re feeding, what you like, and what you want to spend. There may be something better for your table than the bird you originally had in mind.”

Then, with the unmistakable practicality of a man who has spent years behind the meat counter, he added:

“Thanksgiving is about giving thanks. It shouldn’t be about giving away your paycheck.”

____________________________________________________________________________

Editor’s Note: 

Sam’s Meat Warehouse is an independently operated, full-service butcher shop located at 1749 Route 17A, Florida, NY 10921, serving Warwick Valley and surrounding communities. Known for its selection of quality meats, specialty cuts, and personalized butcher service, Sam’s welcomes customers seeking expert advice and honest value.

For holiday orders, product availability, or additional information, call (845) 651-6328 or visit facebook.com/SamsMeatWarehouse.

Sam’s Meat Warehouse is not affiliated with, owned by, operated by, or otherwise associated with any other meat or butcher shops.